The 9th circuit has finally brought down the curtain on the decadelong dispute between omega, the watch manufacturer, and costco, the discount retailer, and decided that costco can. Defendant costco wholesale corporation is not an authorized retailer of omega watches, but in 2004 costco acquired seamaster watches bearing the globe design on the gray market, from third parties that acquired the watches through omegas authorized foreign distributors. Supreme court to hear case on costco resale of watches wsj. Omega the patent angle the worlds largest chipmaker hopes to use a supreme court case about omega watches to. Be sure to check address notes any time you place an order to be sure they are accurate, as they carry over from past orders. Justice kagan took no part in the consideration or decision of the case.
Federal court rules in favor of costco in graymarket omega watch case. Omega contends that costcos sale infringes on their of the omega logo on the back face of the watch. Omega drops gray market high court case against costco. Supreme court will examine costco sale of omega watches. The switzerlandbased watchmaker omega sold seamaster collection watches, which were affixed with its ed logo, in the united states as well as in foreign markets. Supplemental brief of petitioner costco wholesale corporation filed. Equally divided supreme court affirms ninth circuit ruling. The court evenly split 44 on the case of costco wholesale corp.
The judgment is affirmed by an equally divided court. Basically, omega sued costco for selling its watches as an unauthorized distributor by obtaining them through the gray market and reselling them. Costco case study and strategic analysis costco wholesale corporation costco, one among the few largest wholesaler giant differentiates itself applying unique strategies relating to production and operations, and marketing which make it stand out from the rest of the retailers who are also said to be competitive in the retailing and wholesaling. Get it delivered to your doorstep fresh handpicked groceries from. The misuse doctrine renders a unenforceable when it. Justice kagan took no part in the consideration or decision of this case. The first ruling on the case happened in 2008, and the 9 th u. The agents sold the watches to unidentified parties who sold them to a u. Therefore, application of the first sale doctrine disposes of omegas claim, resolves this case in costcos favor, and conclusively reaffirms that. Recommendation expand the kirkland brand into more of costcos product line.
Merits briefsbrief for petitioner costco wholesale corp. Such a split decision upholds the lower courts ruling, which in this case was in favor of omega. Schedule the delivery get your groceries in as little as an hour, or when you want them. This is a huge win for them from a lot of viewpoints, watches, books, clothing etc. The statute would not apply because omega made copies of the omega globe design in switzerland and costco sold the copies without omegas authority in the united states. Federal court rules in favor of costco in graymarket. Luxury omega watches available at costco get em before. As a result, the previous decision in favor of omega was upheld. So, omega sued costco to the us district court for the central district of california.
Court rules costco can sell greymarket omega watches. We are excited to bring you a costco products project that we work hard to keep updated for you and we hope will be. Listen as our authoritative panel of attorneys examines the first sales doctrine and recent developments in the case law and when and where the doctrine applies and offers best practices for protecting ip rights. This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the omega s. Sufficient intake of omega3s can significantly reduce the risk of heart disease, while supporting memory and brain health, promoting healthy cholesterol and triglyceride levels.
On writ of certiorari to the united states court of appeals for the ninth circuit december, 2010 per curiam. Many years ago, omega gave costco the authorization to sell the watches in the foreign market, but they did not give them a mandate for sale in the united states. Omega priced watches in the united states market higher than elsewhere. Costco appealed the decision and brought the case to the supreme court, where the justices split 44 and declined to issue a ruling. Omega stepped in an attempt to control the distribution of its watches and technically won a split decision 44 by the supreme court, with one judge abstaining, so the lower courts ruling in omega. It was a typical costco deal, almost too good to be true. As costco points out in its brief, for years omega didnt mind what costco was doing.
Reply of petitioner costco wholesale corporation filed. This 1050 mg dose, the suit says, is comprised of 720 mg of omega fatty acids 5, 6, 7, 9 and 11, as well as 330 mg of total omega3 fatty acids. Kirkland products have a larger profit margin have more control over manufacturers more alternatives for vertical integration low risk investment current. I am thinking as to costco, they are a company that was financially able and willing to stand up to swatch. Costco, the discount retailer, sold luxury omega watches without the authorization of the swiss watchmaker. Shop watches for men and women at to find the perfect piece of jewelry for you or your loved one at a great value today. States of omega seamaster luxury watches without omegas permission. Costco pharmacy vs omega xl strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Click here to start a new topic please sign and date your posts by typing four tildes new to wikipedia. An equally divided court affirmed the ninth circuits holding that the first sale doctrine applies only to ed items that are made and distributed in.
In this case, you can contact your shopper directly. The omega team is available from 8am to 6pm est, monday to friday. Costco is a united states corporation that has offices in europe and asia. Omega originally sold the watches to authorized agents located outside the u. The decision is the latest installment in the litigation between omega and costco, which began in 2004. Amicus briefs brief for the retail industry leaders association, the national association of chain drug stores, inc.
Merits briefs brief for petitioner costco wholesale corp. Kirkland signature fish oil is a very popular and one of the cheapest options. Costco case study and strategic analysis term paper. If omega has a problem with costco selling gray market watches, the court says, they need to use a different tactic. The dispute in this case surrounds the statutory interpretation of the. Omega sa voluntarily dismissed its petition asking the high court to overturn a january ruling by the ninth circuit in favor of costco wholesale corp. Costco wholesale corporation costco, a discount warehouse, and omega s. Get costco delivered in 3 easy steps order fresh groceries online shop at costco from any device. Costco products price list with costco prices and. We would like to show you a description here but the site wont allow us. Costco later resold those watches in the united states. Omega constellation coaxial star yellow gold mens watch. Application of the first sale doctrine disposes of omegas claim, resolves this case in costcos favor, and conclusively.
For many years, costco sold omega watches that costco legally obtained. Omega is embroiled in a courtroom battle in the us against wholesaletoretail business costco over the sale of its seamaster watches. The supreme court divided equally on the costco question, thereby affirming the decision of the ninth circuit. The company is a warehousebased retailer, selling wholesale brandname goods at low retail prices. Costco obtained omegas watches from a third party that had purchased the. Specifically, the case points to the fact that the supplement is advertised to contain 1050mg of omega unsaturated fatty acids per soft gel. Omega is about much more than cheap watches forbes. For many years, costco sold omega watches that costco legally obtained through third party distributors. Supreme court rules against consumers in costco vs. Costco is not an authorised omega retailer but has obtained a shipment of the watch brands seamaster watches through an overseas third party and was selling the timepieces at its stores. A federal judge in california sided with costco, but an appeals court overturned that decision and sided with omega in 2008, saying the. Omega means the ninth circuits ruling in the case that an extraterritorial first sale does not exhaust a owners u.
1442 545 166 265 226 143 513 1318 1374 905 1281 444 1396 1349 686 360 454 849 927 348 1298 593 858 954 638 842 399 593 763 155 582 387 1137 606